How to Strengthen Your Cyber Insurance Posture Before Renewal

If your cyber insurance renewal is coming up, now’s the time to go beyond the basics.  In Part One, we explored how premiums reflect your organization’s true risk posture and why “proof” matters more than promises. 

In Part Two, we go deeper: how to benchmark your coverage, prepare for renewal, and strengthen your readiness before insurers come calling. 

1. Benchmark Your Coverage. Don’t Assume $1M Is Enough 

Many healthcare providers carry a $1M cyber policy, but in today’s environment, that may not cover even a single major incident.  Data recovery, regulatory fines, and ransom negotiations can escalate costs quickly. Work with a cyber broker who understands healthcare risk to benchmark your limits against your real exposure, including PHI breach costs, HIPAA penalties, and business disruption scenarios. (We’ve got one who can review your current coverage.) 

2. Show You’re Prepared, Not Just Equipped 

Having the right tools isn’t enough. Insurers want proof that you have a plan; a tested, documented incident response process, not just EDR, MFA, or email filtering. Preparedness shows you’re proactive, not reactive. It’s the difference between “we had a breach” and “we contained it within hours.”  Documenting and testing that plan can directly improve your renewal terms. 

3. Choose the Right Partners — Because Vendors Matter 

Your risk profile isn’t limited to your own environment.  Insurers now assess who you partner with: your EHR, remote monitoring platforms, and IT service providers. 

“Senior care organizations we support have a clear advantage at renewal because their safeguards are visible, measured, and backed by a defined response plan.  If you’re not an IHS customer, adopt the same mindset: verify everything you depend on, map your risks, and ensure your partners can stand behind their claims.”  — Mark McIntyre, President and Chief Strategy Officer, Integrated Health Systems 

A managed services provider like Integrated Health Systems, specializing in senior and post-acute care, demonstrates that your environment is professionally managed and continuously monitored; exactly what insurers expect to see. 

4. Take the Cyber-Ready Self-Check: Are You Evolved or Endangered? 

Threats are evolving and in senior care, it’s survival of the cyber-fittest.  Before your next renewal, take a few minutes to assess your readiness: 

• Do we know which systems and data are most critical to protect? 

• Have we identified our top threats and conducted a recent vulnerability assessment? 

• Are our security controls layered, and access to sensitive data limited? 

• Do employees know how to spot phishing and social-engineering attempts? 

• Can we detect unusual activity, do we know what “normal” looks like? 

• Do we have a clear, tested incident-response plan that everyone understands? 

• Do we review and update policies, tools, and training regularly? 

Every “yes” strengthens your position with insurers and every “no” highlights where to focus before renewal season.  Being able to prove you’re cyber-ready often determines whether you receive higher premiums or better coverage. 

5. Bring It All Together 

Your insurance rate, coverage, and recovery outcomes all tie back to one thing: how well you can prove readiness.  By combining a clear plan, validated controls, and healthcare-specific partnerships, you can improve coverage quality and lower cost without sacrificing protection. 

The Good News: You Don’t Have to Face This Alone 

By leaning on a trusted IT partner like Integrated Health Systems, you gain: 

• A laid out, prioritized view of vulnerabilities 

• Proactive monitoring that stops threats before they escalate 

• Tested backup and recovery strategies that minimize downtime 

• Strategic planning to ensure your technology evolves with the threat landscape 

If you’re ready to evolve your cybersecurity strategy, we’re here to help. 

Closing Thought 

Cyber insurance isn’t a checkbox, it’s a reflection of trust.  The more evidence you provide that your organization is protected, prepared, and professionally supported, the more favorably insurers respond. 

If you’re responsible for managing organizational risk or renewals, take this as your starting point: assess where you stand, then strengthen what matters most.  Reach out to Integrated Health Systems to benchmark your readiness, validate your safeguards, and ensure your coverage reflects your true protection not your perceived risk. 

Schedule a conversation